Why I Wouldn't Recommend a Marathon to Most People

Last month, I ran a marathon.
42 kilometres took me about 4 hours and 40 minutes, including a stop for a bowl of beef noodles.

But from a longevity point of view, is running a marathon worth it?
If you only count the health benefits against the physical cost, a marathon is an expensive sport. You train for months, keep adding mileage, and pay a high recovery cost for the long runs. On race day, hours of continuous running put heavy loads on your muscles and joints, burn through large amounts of glycogen and other energy reserves, and ask a lot of your ability to recover.
Would I recommend it to the average person? Probably not. For most people, steady exercise, enough muscle mass and cardiovascular fitness, good sleep, a reasonable body fat level, and a decent diet matter more than chasing longer distances.
Still, I understand why so many people run marathons anyway.
Some things are hard to measure with health metrics. Can you stay with a long process that gives you no immediate feedback? Can you tell the difference between feeling tired in your head and being truly tired in your body, and make a decision in that moment? Can you reach the edge of your emotions when your body is pushed to its limit and still finish?
None of this maps to a single medical marker. But it makes up part of what I would call psychological resilience.
So I no longer see the marathon as a healthier way to live. I see it as an experience of testing the edges of body and mind.
Its value may not come entirely from the 42 kilometres. It also comes from what I learned about myself along the way.
Training Was a Trade-off
My preparation was not aggressive.
For about two months, I ran one long run of around 20 km every weekend. The longest was 26 km. I never ran 40 km in training because the recovery cost was too high. A 40 km session could affect my training for a week or longer, and over the whole cycle, it did not seem worth it.
So I chose consistent long runs that let my body adapt to long efforts gradually, while leaving enough room to recover.
That strategy also meant I had little experience of how my body would react after 30 km.
On race day, after 30 km, I ran into a problem I had not expected. I was so hungry that I could barely run.
I took two energy gels, but the hunger barely eased. In that state, my body wanted only hot food.
By then, I was completely worn out. It was raining, and all kinds of emotions kept rising. I knew exactly what stopping to eat would mean.
Then a voice told me to let go of the numbers.
So when I saw a stall on the road, I stopped and ate a bowl of beef noodles.
It sounds funny now. But it took more courage than any training run I have done, and I had to keep reminding myself what mattered most.

Looking back, it taught me something very concrete about long-distance running.
Sports nutrition has plenty of general principles. Endurance exercise needs a steady supply of carbohydrates, and trained endurance athletes can gradually increase their carbohydrate intake and gut tolerance through training.
But in a real race, when you get hungry, whether to push through the hunger, and when a gel stops helping, are things you only learn from your own training. Beyond three hours, individual differences become huge. Everyone needs a different fuelling strategy and has a different experience of their body.
So long-distance training is also a way of getting to know your own body.
This race showed me more clearly that the limits of the body and the limits of the mind are hard to separate.
When the physical challenge approaches its breaking point, what rises first is rarely rational analysis. It is a set of very specific and sometimes uncontrollable emotions: irritation, frustration, pain, and the urge to quit.
In that state, the thinking and reasoning we normally rely on seem to step back, and emotion gets very loud.
Maybe this is why the best athletes train the mind as seriously as they train the body.
Real training may never be only about the body.
To some extent, I see sport as training in how to be with your own emotions.
Long Runs Do Not Have to Run on Willpower
There is one more thing I found by accident during training.
Once a run goes past two or three hours, it becomes very long. Most of the time, you run alone, and your body keeps repeating the same movement. If you only think of it as, “I have to finish 20 km,” it gets boring quickly.
So I decided to turn my weekend long runs into exploration.
Every weekend, I tried to run somewhere different. Sometimes it was a park I had never been to. Sometimes I picked a route that passed an exhibition or a small shop I had never walked into. Sometimes I ran somewhere and then went nearby for a good meal.

That way, a “20 km long run” stopped being a training task and became a small city adventure.
My reason for going out changed. I wanted to see somewhere new, and running 20 km was just the way I got there.
That change mattered a lot. Something that used to need willpower became something I looked forward to every weekend. I would think ahead: Where should I go this week? What is there? What will I eat afterwards?
It may also be the first time I clearly felt that staying with something for a long time does not necessarily require stronger willpower. Sometimes, the better move is to redesign the thing so that it becomes interesting in itself.
This applies to a lot of things. If a behaviour needs you to force yourself every single time, it rarely becomes a lasting habit. If you can connect it to exploration, curiosity, or something else you already enjoy, sticking with it gets much easier.
Heart Rate Over Pace
About 80% of my running during preparation was in Zone 2.
For the first two years, I paid attention to pace. Since last year, I have felt more and more that heart rate tells me more than pace does. Pace is an external result. Heart rate is closer to the physical load my body is carrying right now.
Put simply, pace is for other people to see. Heart rate is about me.
The same 5:30 per km can feel easy on a cool day when I have slept well and feel good. On a hot day, after a bad night, or after a few days of built-up fatigue, the same pace can push my heart rate up noticeably.
Terrain matters too. On a climb, your speed drops, but the load on your body may already have gone up. If you keep staring at pace, it is easy to speed up just to hold the number, and quietly push your effort past the target.
We usually split heart-rate training into five zones.
Zone 1 is very easy recovery work, typically used for warming up, cooling down, and recovery.
Zone 2 is low-intensity aerobic work that you can sustain for a long time, and it is an important zone for building an aerobic base.
Zone 3 raises the intensity noticeably, and breathing gets deeper and faster.
Zone 4 moves closer to the lactate threshold, where the effort becomes much harder to sustain.
Zone 5 is near-maximal effort, closer to speed, power, and maximum cardiovascular capacity, and you can only hold it briefly.

I especially like Zone 2 because it sits at an interesting balance point. It is hard enough to give the body a real aerobic training stimulus, and easy enough to keep going for a long time, with a relatively low recovery cost.
For people who build mileage over the long term, that means you can train again and again without needing long breaks to recover.
This is also why I did not stack up Zone 3, Zone 4, and Zone 5 during preparation. High-intensity work has its value. But if every session chases a faster pace, it is easy to push the body into a state that needs a long time to recover.
A marathon needs accumulated training volume, and I cared more about whether the whole training cycle could keep going steadily.
So heart-rate training feels to me like asking one question:
In Zone 2, what I care about is whether I am staying at an effort I can keep up. A simple check by feel: I can still speak normally while running, my breathing is steady, and I do not need a long time to recover afterwards.
This kind of training looks slow, but it trains one very important ability: whether the body can supply aerobic energy for a long time.
That is where I began to really understand Zone 2.
What Does Zone 2 Have to Do With Mitochondria?
Think of the human body as a system that needs a constant supply of power. Mitochondria can be understood as the energy factories inside our cells.
The carbohydrates, fats, and other nutrients we eat go through a series of metabolic processes, including aerobic metabolism involving the mitochondria, to produce ATP. ATP can be understood as the form of energy cells use directly.
Muscles need to keep producing ATP during long exercise. So the number, function, and oxidative capacity of mitochondria all contribute to our endurance and ability to sustain energy production.
Regular, low-intensity aerobic training like Zone 2 is one of the main ways the body builds more and better mitochondria in the muscles. That is why I spend most of my running time there.
If we want our bodies to last many years, what matters most may be keeping our aerobic system in good working condition over the long term.
Running a marathon once in a while can test your limit.
What daily training builds is the body's ability to keep working when it is not being pushed to the limit.
The Question the Marathon Left Me
Seen this way, a marathon is a very concentrated experiment. In a few hours, it gave me fatigue, hunger, fuelling, resilience, and the limits of my body. It also made me look again at the less exciting training I do every day, and at the steadier state of mind that comes with it.
More worth thinking about than the number 42.195 km is this: how to train, how to recover, how to eat, and how to live with my own body and brain, so that all of it becomes something I can keep doing for decades.
But why do I still want to do this now and then?
I want to see where my emotional edge is when my body is pushed to its limit.
上个月,我跑了一场马拉松。
整场下来 42 公里,最后用了大约 4 小时 40 分钟,中间还停下来吃了碗牛肉面。

但如果从长期健康(longevity)的角度来看,跑一场全马到底值不值得?
如果只计算健康收益和身体成本,全马是一项投入很高的运动。为了完成 42 公里,需要提前几个月的训练,持续增加跑量,也要为长距离训练付出相当高的恢复成本。真正比赛的时候,几个小时的持续运动会给肌肉和关节带来很大的负荷,同时持续消耗大量糖原和其他能量储备,对身体的恢复能力也提出了很高的要求。
普通人适不适合跑全马?我大概不会建议。对大多数人来说,长期稳定地运动,保持足够的肌肉量和心肺能力,睡好觉,维持合理的体脂和饮食,可能比不断挑战更长的距离更重要。
可我也理解了,为什么还是有很多人愿意跑马拉松。
有些东西很难用健康指标去衡量。比如我们能不能忍受一个漫长而没有即时反馈的过程,能不能在情绪觉得自己累和身体真正累的时候做决断,以及在极限的时候去到情绪边界而又最终完成,这些能力未必对应某一个医学指标,但它们确实构成了我们面对自我时的一部分心理韧性。
所以我现在不会把全马理解成一种"更健康的生活方式",我更愿意把它看成一次对身体和心理边界的体验。
训练本身也是一次取舍
我的备赛没有特别激进。
大概有两个月的时间,我每个周末都跑一次 20 公里左右的长距离,最长跑过 26 公里。我从来没有在训练里跑过 40 公里,因为恢复成本太高。一次 40 公里的训练,很可能影响接下来一周甚至更长时间的运动和训练质量,对整个备赛周期来说未必划算。
所以我选择用持续的长距离让身体逐渐适应长时间运动,同时给自己留出足够的恢复空间。
这个策略也意味着,我对 30 公里之后的身体反应没有太多经验。
比赛当天,30 公里之后,我遇到了一个完全没有预料到的问题:我饿得不行,几乎很难跑起来。
补了 2 次能量胶之后,饥饿感几乎没有缓解,而且我的身体在极度饥饿的时候,只想要热食。
而 30 公里之后意味着身体极度疲乏,并且当时还下雨,各种情绪不断涌现出来……我很清楚停下来吃东西意味着什么,直到最后有个声音告诉我……放弃那些数字。
所以在路上看到一个摊位,我直接停下来,吃了一碗牛肉面。
做这个决定现在看来有点搞笑,但是它确实比过去任何长跑训练更需要勇气,而且你还得不断告诉自己什么才是最重要的。

现在回头看,这件事让我对长距离运动有了一个很具体的认识。
运动营养有很多通用原则。长时间耐力运动需要持续补充碳水,训练良好的耐力运动员也可以通过训练,逐渐提高碳水摄入量和胃肠道的耐受能力。但到了真正的比赛里,一个人什么时候开始饿,要不要为了忍受饥饿继续跑,能量胶在什么时候对自己帮助有限,都需要通过自己的训练去了解。跑超过 3 个小时之后,个体差异非常大,每个人需要的补给策略和身体体验完全不同。
所以,长距离训练也是在认识自己的身体。
这次让我更深地意识到,身体的极限和心理的极限其实很难完全分开。
当身体的挑战逐渐接近临界点,最先涌上来的往往不是理性的分析,而是各种非常具体、甚至有些失控的情绪:烦躁、委屈、痛苦、想放弃……
在那个状态里,我们平时依赖的认知和理性好像都会往后退一步,而情绪会变得非常大。
这也是为什么顶尖运动员都是心理大师。真正的训练可能从来不只是身体。
长距离训练不一定要靠意志力完成
还有一件事,是我在备赛过程中意外发现的。
长跑超过两三个小时以后,过程非常漫长。大部分时间你都一个人跑,身体不断做着重复的动作。如果只把它理解成"我要完成 20 公里",这个过程很容易变得无聊。
所以我后来干脆把周末的长跑变成了探索。
备赛的每个周末,我都尽量换一个不同的地方跑。我可能跑去一个之前没去过的公园,或路线看看附近有没有展览,经过一家从来没进去过的小店,或者跑完以后去附近吃一顿好吃的。

这样一来,"20 公里长跑"就不再只是一个训练任务,而变成了一次城市探索。
我出门的理由,变成了想去一个新的地方,跑 20 公里只是顺便过去的方式。
这个变化对我的影响很大。原本需要意志力才能完成的事情,变成了我每个周末都会期待的事情。我会提前想:这周去哪里?那边有什么?跑完吃点什么?
这可能也是我第一次比较明显地感受到,长期坚持未必来自更强的意志力。有时候更有效的办法,是重新设计这件事,让它本身变得有趣。
很多事情都是一样的。如果一个行为每一次都需要靠"逼自己"才能完成,它很难真正成为长期习惯。反过来,如果能把它和探索、好奇心,或者其他你本来就喜欢的事情连接起来,坚持就会容易很多。
跑步,我更在意心率,而不是配速
整个备赛期间,我大概 80% 的跑量都控制在 Zone 2。
我前两年也会关注配速,但从去年开始,我越来越觉得,在跑步训练里,心率比配速更有参考价值。配速是一个外在结果,但心率更接近身体当下正在承受的生理负荷。更简单地说,配速是给别人看的,心率才是关乎自己的。
比如同样是 5 分 30 秒一公里,在天气凉爽、睡眠充足、状态很好的一天,可能非常轻松。如果天气很热、前一天没睡好,或者前几天已经积累了很多疲劳,同样的配速可能会让心率明显升高。
地形也会影响配速。上坡的时候速度自然会下降,身体的负荷却可能已经明显增加。如果一直盯着配速,很容易为了维持数字而强行加速,让训练强度悄悄超过原本的目标。
通常我们会把心率训练简单分成五个区间。
Zone 1 是非常轻松的恢复区,通常用于热身、放松和恢复。
Zone 2 依然属于低强度有氧运动,可以持续比较长的时间,也是建立有氧基础的重要区间。
Zone 3 的强度开始明显提高,呼吸会变得更深更快,属于中等强度。
Zone 4 训练已经接近乳酸阈值,身体会产生更多乳酸,能够维持的时间明显缩短。
Zone 5 是接近最大努力的高强度区间,更接近速度、爆发力和最大心肺能力,通常只能维持比较短的时间。

我尤其喜欢 Zone 2,是因为它处在一个很有意思的平衡点:强度已经足够让身体产生有氧训练刺激,同时又低到可以持续比较长的时间,恢复成本也相对低。对于需要长期积累跑量的人来说,这意味着你可以反复训练,不需要每次都花很长时间恢复。
这也是我在备赛期间没有大量堆积 Zone 3、Zone 4 和 Zone 5 的原因。高强度训练当然有它的价值,但如果每一次训练都追求更快的配速,很容易把身体推到一个需要较长恢复时间的状态。马拉松需要持续积累训练量,我更在意整个训练周期能不能稳定地进行下去。
所以心率训练给我的感觉,更像是在问:
在 Zone 2 的训练里,我更关心自己有没有保持在一个可以持续工作的强度。一个简单的体感判断是:跑步的时候仍然可以正常说话,呼吸比较稳定,跑完以后也不会觉得需要很长时间才能恢复。
这种训练看起来很慢,却在训练一个非常重要的能力:身体能不能长时间地进行有氧供能。
我就是从这里开始真正理解 Zone 2 的。
Zone 2 和线粒体到底有什么关系?
如果把人体想象成一个需要持续供电的系统,线粒体可以理解为细胞里的"能量工厂"。
我们吃进去的碳水、脂肪等营养物质,经过一系列代谢过程,在线粒体参与的有氧代谢中产生 ATP。ATP 可以理解成细胞直接使用的能量形式。
肌肉在长时间运动的时候需要持续制造 ATP,所以线粒体的数量、功能和氧化代谢能力,都会影响我们的耐力和能量。
长期规律的低强度有氧训练,比如 Zone 2,是身体在肌肉里增加线粒体数量、提升线粒体功能的主要方式之一。所以我把大部分跑量放在这里。
如果我们希望身体可以使用很多年,真正重要的可能是让自己的有氧系统长期保持良好的工作能力。
偶尔跑一次全马,可以测试自己的极限。
日常训练真正积累的,是身体在没有被推到极限的情况下,持续工作的能力。
所以,全马最后留给我的问题不是我能跑多远多快
从这个角度看,全马更像一次很集中的实验。它让我在几个小时里体验了疲劳、饥饿、补给、心理韧性和身体极限,也让我重新认识了平时那些看起来没有那么刺激的训练和相对平稳的心理状况。
比 42.195 公里这串数字更值得认真思考的:
是怎样训练,怎样恢复,怎样吃饭,怎样和自己的身体和大脑相处,才能让这件事变成一个可以持续几十年的过程。
但我为什么还是偶尔想这么做: